The Billionaire Tax Lost After Its Biggest Targets Left
California's wealth tax would have hit every billionaire living there last New Year's Day, ten months before the vote that killed it.
The week between Christmas and New Year's is the quietest of the year. Offices are dark, half the country is away, and nothing is supposed to happen. Last year in California something did.
On Friday, Dec. 26, the secretary of state announced that the sponsor of a tax on billionaires could begin collecting signatures to put it on the ballot. The tax was 5 percent of a billionaire's net worth, one time. It would fall on every billionaire who was a resident of California the following Thursday, which was New Year's Day.
Some of them had not waited. Sergey Brin, a founder of Google and the second-richest man in the state, changed his voter registration to Nevada on Dec. 10, according to records Forbes obtained, and bought a house on the Nevada side of Lake Tahoe. Larry Page, the richest, bought two that winter in Miami.
Travis Kalanick, who helped start Uber, told an interviewer, "Just to be clear, on December 18, I moved to Texas. I don't know what's so specific about December 18, but let's just say it's prior to January."
On Nov. 3 the tax lost, 52 percent to 48.
Mr. Brin gave more than $100 million to defeat the measure and could not cast a ballot against it. By then he had been a Nevada voter for nearly eleven months.
For a year the argument in California was about the 5 percent. I think the worst thing in the measure was the date. It is one line in the text: "'Tax obligation date' means January 1, 2026." Six days after the first signature could be gathered, and ten months before Election Day, the roll was closed. If you were a billionaire in California that morning you owed, wherever you were living by the time the votes were counted.
I understand the logic. A wealth tax announced ahead of time is a tax on people who are slow to pack, so the door had to shut first. The first draft, filed in October of last year, shut it on a day already past. A billionaire who had left California since would still have owed 75 percent of the tax. In late November the sponsor took that out, and what remained gave anyone with a lawyer and a second house a good five weeks.
I don't hold it against the ones who left. Americans have always been free to go, and California is full of the grandchildren of people who left somewhere else. Steven Spielberg became a New Yorker that New Year's Day, and his spokeswoman said it was to be nearer his children and grandchildren. I believe her.
But the date was only ever going to catch the ones who stayed. Jensen Huang, the Nvidia founder, said he was "perfectly fine" with the tax, and Forbes put his bill at about $9 billion.
California's tax agency publishes a guide to deciding who is a resident, and I like its first principle: "you are a resident of the place where you have the closest connections." It says to look at where your spouse and children are, where you vote, where your doctors and dentist are, where you worship. That is as good a definition of home as I know.
Under Proposition 40 it was also how the state would have decided whom to bill. The more completely a person belonged to California on New Year's morning, the more surely the tax would find him.
Now remember who voted on it. Everyone who marked a California ballot was, by definition, someone who had stayed. And they were not shy about taxing the rich. On the same ballot, by 61 percent, they made permanent the higher income-tax rates on the state's top earners, the 2 percent of taxpayers who already pay about half of all the income tax California collects.
They turned down the wealth tax. Think of what it would have cost them to go the other way, which was nothing. Almost none of them would ever have owed a dollar of it. The few it was aimed at are not much loved, and the measure did not pretend otherwise: it called what it taxed "the activity of sustaining excessive accumulations of wealth," which is a long way of saying still having it. Most of the money was for the sick. Would you have said no? I find I am moved, more than I expected to be by a tax vote, that people with children and doctors and a pew in that state, who could no more have left it in five weeks than moved the house, were offered something for nothing and a majority of them looked at it and said no.
I can't see into that many hearts, but I can read the rest of the ballot. By 51 percent they passed Proposition 42, which puts two plain things into the state constitution. California may lay no new tax on a person's savings, his investments or his pension merely because he has them. And no ballot initiative may tax anyone for where he lived, or what he did, before it passed.
Put the three votes together and you have a rule a child could state. You may tax what people earn, even heavily, at a rate posted in advance. You may not tax what they have saved. And you may not hold a vote in November on what they owed in January.
I would have voted against the permanent rates. I think they are too high, and that the people who pay them are owed more thanks than they get. But a rate is a thing you can know. You can read it, resent it, plan around it, pay it or leave ahead of it.
The Supreme Court was once asked to rule out a tax that reached back, and declined. The man who asked was an executor named Jerry Carlton. In the last week of 1986, the same quiet week this column began with, he filed an estate's tax return claiming a deduction that a new law, as written, allowed. Before the next year was out Congress changed the law and backdated the change, and he paid, with interest, and in 1994 he lost without a dissent. Justice Antonin Scalia called it "bait-and-switch taxation" and ruled against him anyway. "Tax legislation is not a promise," the Court said.
The people who stayed have now made each other that promise. I wish the right rule had been sold under its own name. Its sponsors called it the Retirement and Personal Savings Protection Act, though the tax it was written to stop was a tax on billionaires. I think the billionaires who paid for most of that campaign had the true argument, the one about the date, and did not lead with it.
The people who wrote the tax put their reasons into it, and one line has stayed with me: Medi-Cal covers half of all the births in the state. Half the babies in California. That need did not go away on Election Day, and the program stands to lose billions a year in federal money. The union behind the tax has said it will try again in 2028 if the Legislature does not find the money, and it can, because what one initiative writes into a constitution another can take out.
The ones who stayed will pay a great deal to live where their closest connections are, the richest of them most of all. What they ask is to be told the price before the day it is due.
Sources
- California Secretary of State, news release, "Proposed Initiative Enters Circulation: Imposes One-Time Tax On Certain Individuals And Trusts" (Dec. 26, 2025). The proponent was cleared to begin collecting petition signatures on Dec. 26, 2025; 874,641 signatures required; Attorney General No. 25-0024A1.
- Proposition 40, the 2026 Billionaire Tax Act, Text of Proposed Laws, California Official Voter Information Guide, Nov. 3, 2026 General Election, pp. 134, 137-138, 144-145 (findings (b), (c) and (f); proposed Gov. Code § 16355(b)(1); proposed Rev. & Tax. Code §§ 50301(a)-(b), 50308(a), (n), (o)). The 5 percent one-time tax on individuals with net worth of $1 billion or more; residency fixed "as of the tax obligation date," defined as January 1, 2026; the tax described as an excise "on the activity of sustaining excessive accumulations of wealth"; ninety percent of the money allocated to health care; the findings on Medi-Cal, including "half of all births statewide" and the projected loss of federal funding.
- Richard Nieva and Matt Durot, "Sergey Brin Registered To Vote In Nevada Amid California Billionaire Tax Frenzy," Forbes (Oct. 16, 2026). Cited for what it reported: Brin's voter registration changed to Nevada on Dec. 10, per Nevada Secretary of State records; his house on the Nevada side of Lake Tahoe; Page's two Miami houses, bought in December 2025 and January 2026; both men's spokespeople on their new residency; Page and Brin as the state's two richest residents; more than $100 million donated by Brin, who could not vote on the measure.
- Sydney Lake, report on Travis Kalanick's move to Texas ahead of California's billionaire tax, Fortune (Oct. 27, 2026). Cited for Kalanick's statement to the program TBPN, as Fortune quoted it.
- KQED, "Live Election Results for California's Proposition 40 in 2026," Associated Press count, as read Nov. 19, 2026. No 52.1 percent (6,790,200 votes), Yes 47.8 percent (6,231,990), with 98.46 percent of the vote counted; race called Nov. 9, 2026.
- Gary S. Winuk, Kaufman Legal Group, letter to Attorney General Rob Bonta for proponents Jim Mangia and Suzanne Jimenez requesting a title and summary for the "2026 Billionaire Tax Act," Initiative No. 25-0024 (Oct. 21, 2025; stamped received Oct. 22, 2025), with the original text, §§ 50306 and 50308(a), (l) at pp. 18-20 of 24, Internet Archive capture of Oct. 24, 2025. As first filed, the measure reached California residents "as assessed on January 1, 2025," and multiplied the tax by 75 percent for those who were no longer residents on January 1, 2026.
- Suzanne Jimenez, proponent, letter to Attorney General Rob Bonta enclosing the first amendment to Initiative No. 25-0024, the "2026 Billionaire Tax Act" (Nov. 24, 2025), with the amended text, §§ 50306(a), 50308(a), (n) at pp. 21-22, 24-25 of 32. The amended measure, carrying the January 1, 2026 tax obligation date, was submitted under a letter dated Nov. 24, 2025, and stamped received on Nov. 26, 36 days before that date. As amended, the measure counts residents on that date alone and apportions the tax "without reduction or multiplier based on residency history."
- Mary Whitfill Roeloffs, "These Billionaires Who Left California Would Save The Most If Wealth Tax Passes," Forbes (Oct. 31, 2026). Cited for what it reported: Jensen Huang has said he is "perfectly fine" with the tax and would owe about $9 billion.
- Seema Mehta, "Billionaires Spielberg, Zuckerberg eyeing East Coast, stirring concerns about California's wealth-tax proposal," Los Angeles Times, as republished by Yahoo News (Feb. 19, 2026). Cited for what it reported: Spielberg and Kate Capshaw became residents of New York City on Jan. 1, and his spokesperson said the move was to be closer to their children and grandchildren.
- California Franchise Tax Board, Publication 1031, Guidelines for Determining Resident Status (2025), Section G, p. 5. "The underlying theory of residency is that you are a resident of the place where you have the closest connections," with the listed factors.
- KQED, "Live Election Results for California's Proposition 3 in 2026," Associated Press count, as read Nov. 19, 2026. Yes 60.7 percent (7,857,464 votes), No 39.2 percent.
- Legislative Analyst, Analysis of Proposition 3, California Official Voter Information Guide, Nov. 3, 2026 General Election. Proposition 3 makes permanent the rates voters approved in Proposition 30 in 2012; the top 2 percent of taxpayers pay them, and those taxpayers pay about half of all state income taxes.
- KQED, "Live Election Results for California's Proposition 42 in 2026," Associated Press count, as read Nov. 19, 2026. Yes 51.2 percent (6,610,065 votes), No 48.7 percent; race called Nov. 13, 2026.
- Proposition 42, the Retirement and Personal Savings Protection Act of 2026, Text of Proposed Laws, California Official Voter Information Guide, Nov. 3, 2026 General Election, pp. 150-152 (proposed Cal. Const. art. VIII, §§ 1(a), 2(a)(1)-(2), 2(c), 3(a), 4). No new state tax on the ownership of "retirement holdings, individually owned assets, and other forms of personal savings," defined to include pensions, retirement accounts and investment accounts; no tax "that operates retroactively," including one based on "residency status on a date prior to the effective date of the tax," the only exception being for a statute passed by the Legislature in a declared emergency; the article applies to statewide initiative measures; the short title its sponsors gave the act in section 1.
- United States v. Carlton, 512 U.S. 26, 28-29, 33-34, 39 (1994). The executor, Jerry W. Carlton, filed the estate's return on Dec. 29, 1986, claiming a new estate tax deduction; the Court allowed that his reading of the original statute "appears to have been correct"; Congress amended the statute on Dec. 22, 1987, effective as of its October 1986 enactment; he paid the deficiency plus interest; the Court upheld the retroactive amendment with no dissent, setting apart at 34 "the creation of a wholly new tax"; "Tax legislation is not a promise"; Justice Scalia, concurring in the judgment, on "bait-and-switch taxation."
- Yue Stella Yu, Kristen Hwang and Jeanne Kuang, "California billionaires faced down a tax and won new protections for their wealth," CalMatters (Nov. 5, 2026). Cited for what it reported: Proposition 42 was put on the ballot to cancel out the wealth tax, was promoted in ads and mailers as protection for pensions and retirement accounts, and was "primarily bankrolled by billionaires"; voters could undo the ban with a later ballot measure.
- Kristen Hwang, "California voters reject Prop. 40 billionaire tax," CalMatters (Nov. 9, 2026). Cited for what it reported: the union behind the tax vowed to try again in 2028 if the Legislature "fails to deliver a real solution" to fund health care.
Columns are the views of their authors. They are not legal advice and not the position of the firm.