Washington banned a drug it can't spell
The federal ban on hemp THC began taking effect on November 12, and the list that says what it covers is nine months late.
The United States has outlawed a drug it cannot spell, and the proof is at page 561 of volume 139 of the Statutes at Large, where Congress orders the Food and Drug Administration to publish "a list of all other know cannabinoids with similar effects to, or marketed to have similar effects to, tetrahyrocannabinol class cannabinoids." The word wanted is tetrahydrocannabinol, the part of marijuana that does the work, THC for short. The section gets it right twelve times before getting it wrong, so we know about where the proofreader went home. Thirty-six days after signing it the President took his own run at the word, in Executive Order 14370, and came down on "tetrahydracannabinol."
Spelling is a small thing, and I'd let it pass if the law weren't in force. Since last Thursday, part of it is. As of November 12 a hemp product containing any cannabinoid "not capable of being naturally produced" by the cannabis plant has stopped being hemp, and a cannabis product that isn't hemp is, as a rule, marijuana. The rest arrives December 11. The statute promised a list of the cannabinoids the plant can produce and gave the FDA ninety days to publish it; the FDA has so far taken 371, and the Congressional Research Service reported on October 28 that it had published none. The FDA's website says the plant makes "over 80" cannabinoids on one page and "over 100" on another, so I can see the difficulty. Still, when a government bans something, its first job is knowing what.
The man who started this is Mitch McConnell, and he started it with a pen. On the night of December 10, 2018, the Senate majority leader signed the farm bill's conference report with what he told the Senate the next morning was "my very own hemp pen." American-grown hemp, he said, could already be found "in your food, your clothes, and even in your car dashboard." His provision defined hemp, in one sentence of fifty-one words, as any part of the cannabis plant and "all derivatives, extracts, cannabinoids," with no more than 0.3 percent of one kind of THC, delta-9, "on a dry weight basis."
That is a sensible way to tell rope from dope in a field. Then somebody applied it to a drink. Three-tenths of one percent of a twelve-ounce can of seltzer comes to about a gram of THC, so everything passed: the gummies, the vapes, the chips and, by the Associated Press's account, the seltzers "sold at some Target stores," a retail trade one market study said in September stands to lose $28.3 billion. A federal appeals court had a look in 2022, in a trademark fight over a vape called Cake, found that the fifty-one words meant what they said, and added that if Congress had "inadvertently created a loophole," then "it is for Congress to fix its mistake."
Congress fixed it a year ago last Thursday, at page 558 of the 161-page bill that reopened the government, between a paragraph holding off an FDA food-tracing rule until 2028 and $2 million for processors of "invasive, wild-caught catfish." (The catfish, as far as I can tell, are spelled correctly.) The fifty-one words became about nine hundred. From December 11 a finished hemp product may hold no more than 0.4 milligrams of THC "per container," which for the can is a markdown from about a gram to four ten-thousandths of one. Congress, like the shower at my house, has two settings. The 0.4 counts any cannabinoid "marketed to have similar effects," so a gummy can become a controlled substance by bragging.
McConnell's press release said in its headline that his provision "Protects Industrial Hemp and CBD," CBD being the cannabinoid nobody takes to get high. The President's executive order, the one with the spelling, reported that some CBD products "will once again be controlled as marijuana," and told a deputy chief of staff to "work with the Congress" on changing the definition he had signed five weeks before.
The senators who wanted the ban have a point, and in August Ted Budd of North Carolina carried it onto the Senate floor in the form of products called Slizzles and Stoneo, in packaging he called "unmistakably designed to appeal to kids." The FDA has reported 2,362 poison-control cases in 2021 and early 2022 involving delta-8 THC, usually made from hemp, 41 percent involving patients under eighteen, one of whom died, and notes that the stuff sells at gas stations "where there may not be age limits."
I am a libertarian, not a lunatic, and nobody's liberty includes selling Slizzles to a fourth grader. But this country long ago worked out how to keep an intoxicant from children while letting their parents have it, and the invention is called a liquor license. McConnell's release quotes a professor who says that to claim hemp needs THC "is like saying corn farmers can't thrive without moonshine." In Kentucky corn farmers thrive on moonshine with a label, a tax and a minimum age, under the name of bourbon, and in March 2025 the Kentucky legislature gave THC drinks the same treatment: five milligrams to the twelve-ounce serving, under the Department of Alcoholic Beverage Control, with liquor's age limit. Congress's limit is less than a tenth of Kentucky's, and it applies to grown-ups.
The Senate had voted 76 to 24 to keep McConnell's ban in the bill. Nine months later, at 2:36 on the morning of August 8, it voted 61 to 32 to keep a provision putting most of the ban off until December 11. The provision is one sentence of fifty-three words, none of which is "hemp." McConnell had put his name on the amendment to strike it. So the cannabinoids the plant can't make went out on schedule last week, and everything else got twenty-nine days, which is supposed to be time enough for Congress to write the rules it didn't write in the previous 365, or the seven years before those.
The executive branch, meanwhile, has gone into licensing. On October 30 the Justice Department announced that the Drug Enforcement Administration was registering "more than 900" medical marijuana dispensaries in Alabama, Florida, Mississippi, South Dakota, Texas, Virginia and West Virginia. "The American people deserve access to the best medical treatments in the world," said Attorney General Todd Blanche. It is one molecule, and this week the THC in a registered dispensary in Mississippi is Schedule III medicine, the THC in a shop licensed by the State of Illinois to sell to adults is Schedule I contraband, as marijuana has been since 1970, and the THC in a can of seltzer at Target is an unscheduled farm product with twenty-three days left on the clock.
I'd settle for the rules we apply to beer, and so would the man Kentucky elected on November 3 to take McConnell's seat. Representative Andy Barr's Lawful Hemp Protection Act, introduced in July, would bar the synthetics, limit sales to people twenty-one and over, route the drinks through distributors and tax them a nickel a milligram, a quarter on a five-milligram can. "Kentucky has demonstrated that hemp can be successfully regulated," Barr said. The bill is supported by the Wine & Spirits Wholesalers of America, who are distributors, and I never expected to hear myself ask Congress for a new tax and a compulsory middleman. I'm asking.
McConnell leaves the Senate in January. The pen, I'm glad to report, is safe. The new definition takes care to protect hemp grown for "the stalk of the plant, fiber produced from such a stalk, or any other non-cannabinoid derivative," so Congress can go on writing laws with it. It might try a dictionary first.
Sources
- Continuing Appropriations, Agriculture, Legislative Branch, Military Construction and Veterans Affairs, and Extensions Act, 2026, Pub. L. 119-37, div. B, §§ 780-782, 139 Stat. 495, 558-561 (Nov. 12, 2025). Section 781: the amended definition of hemp, effective 365 days after enactment; the exclusion of cannabinoids "not capable of being naturally produced"; the limit of 0.4 milligrams per container, counting cannabinoids "marketed to have similar effects"; the protection of industrial hemp; and, at 139 Stat. 560-561, the 90-day direction to the FDA, with "know" and "tetrahyrocannabinol." Sections 780 and 782 are the food traceability and catfish provisions. The law runs 161 pages, 139 Stat. 495-655.
- Executive Order 14370 of December 18, 2025, Increasing Medical Marijuana and Cannabidiol Research, 90 Fed. Reg. 60541, 60542 (Dec. 23, 2025). The spelling "tetrahydracannabinol"; the statement that some full-spectrum CBD products will again be controlled as marijuana when section 781 takes effect; and section 2(b), directing a deputy chief of staff to work with the Congress to update the definition.
- Dorothy C. Kafka and Joanna R. Lampe, Delay in Changes to Hemp Definition: Cannabinoids Not Capable of Being Naturally Produced by the Cannabis Plant, Congressional Research Service Legal Sidebar LSB11496, at 2-3 (Oct. 28, 2026). Cannabis is marijuana under federal law unless it qualifies as hemp, and hemp is not a controlled substance; marijuana in Schedule I since 1970; the April 2026 order moving state-licensed medical marijuana to Schedule III; what took effect on November 12, 2026; and the report that the FDA had published none of the lists.
- Food and Drug Administration, "FDA and Cannabis: Research and Drug Approval Process" (content current as of Feb. 24, 2023; retrieved Nov. 18, 2026). The plant "contains over 80 different naturally occurring compounds called 'cannabinoids.'"
- Food and Drug Administration, "5 Things to Know about Delta-8 Tetrahydrocannabinol" (content current as of May 4, 2022; retrieved Nov. 18, 2026). Delta-8 THC as "one of over 100 cannabinoids produced naturally by the cannabis plant," typically manufactured from hemp-derived CBD; 2,362 poison-control exposure cases from January 1, 2021 to February 28, 2022, 41 percent of them pediatric, one coded with an outcome of death; and sales at gas stations and convenience stores.
- 164 Cong. Rec. S7390 (daily ed. Dec. 11, 2018) (statement of Sen. McConnell). The hemp pen, the signing of the farm bill conference report the night before, and "in your food, your clothes, and even in your car dashboard."
- 7 U.S.C. § 1639o(1) (2024 ed.), added by the Agriculture Improvement Act of 2018, Pub. L. 115-334, § 10113, 132 Stat. 4490, 4908 (Dec. 20, 2018). The 2018 definition of hemp: one sentence, 51 words, 0.3 percent delta-9 THC on a dry weight basis.
- Gene Johnson, "A $28 billion hemp THC industry is fighting to save itself from a looming federal ban," Associated Press via PBS News (Oct. 3, 2026). Cited for what it reported: how the 2018 definition let beverages and snacks qualify as hemp; gummies, vapes and chips; THC seltzers "sold at some Target stores"; and the Whitney Economics estimate, in a report released in September 2026, that the ban threatens to reduce retail revenues by $28.3 billion.
- AK Futures LLC v. Boyd Street Distro, LLC, No. 21-56133, 35 F.4th 682 (9th Cir. May 19, 2022), slip op. at 5-6, 14, 20. The Cake-branded delta-8 vaping products, the trademark dispute, the plain-meaning reading of the 2018 definition, and "it is for Congress to fix its mistake."
- Office of Sen. Mitch McConnell, "McConnell Hemp Provision Targets Intoxicating THC Products; Protects Industrial Hemp and CBD" (Nov. 10, 2025). The headline, the senator's description of his provision, and the quoted op-ed by Dr. Matt Rossheim with the corn and moonshine comparison.
- 172 Cong. Rec. S4463-S4464 (daily ed. Aug. 5, 2026) (statement of Sen. Budd). The products named Slizzles and Stoneo and "unmistakably designed to appeal to kids."
- Kentucky General Assembly, 2025 Regular Session, Senate Bill 202, 2025 Ky. Acts ch. 82 (signed Mar. 25, 2025). Cannabis-infused beverages limited to five milligrams per 12-ounce serving, placed under the Department of Alcoholic Beverage Control, with age restrictions identical to those for alcoholic beverages.
- U.S. Senate, Roll Call Vote No. 614, 119th Cong., 1st Sess. (Nov. 10, 2025). Motion to table Paul Amendment No. 3941, which would have struck the hemp provision, agreed to 76-24.
- U.S. Senate, Roll Call Vote No. 227, 119th Cong., 2d Sess. (Aug. 8, 2026, 2:36 a.m.). Motion to table Budd Amendment No. 6747, "To strike section 2019," agreed to 61-32.
- Continuing Appropriations and Extensions Act, 2027, Pub. L. 119-103, div. B, § 2019, 140 Stat. 987, 1003 (Sept. 2, 2026). The one-sentence delay: until December 11, 2026, section 781 applies only to products containing cannabinoids not capable of being naturally produced by the plant.
- 172 Cong. Rec. S4526-S4527 (daily ed. Aug. 6, 2026) (SA 6747). Amendment No. 6747, submitted by Sen. Budd for himself and fourteen others, Sen. McConnell among them.
- U.S. Department of Justice, Office of Public Affairs, "Justice Department Announces Issuance of Federal Registrations for Medical Marijuana Dispensaries," Press Release No. 26-1276 (Oct. 30, 2026). The first DEA registrations, "more than 900" dispensaries in seven states, the Attorney General's statement, and the note that marijuana outside the order, recreational marijuana included, stays in Schedule I.
- Associated Press, "Republican Andy Barr wins election to U.S. Senate from Kentucky," via OPB (Nov. 3, 2026). Barr's election to the seat Sen. McConnell is vacating.
- Office of Rep. Andy Barr, "Barr Introduces Lawful Hemp Protection Act to Protect Kentucky Farmers, Consumers, and the Future of the Hemp Industry" (July 22, 2026). H.R. 9830: the ban on synthetic cannabinoids, sales limited to those 21 and older, the three-tier system for beverages, the tax of five cents per milligram of THC, the Barr quotation, and the list of supporters.
Columns are the views of their authors. They are not legal advice and not the position of the firm.